Back to database

Bread & Butter Fat Boy 16mm vs Selkirk Vanguard Control S2 (midweight)

Side-by-side comparison with lab-tested specs

Specs Comparison

Spec
Bread & Butter Fat Boy 16mm
Selkirk Vanguard Control S2 (midweight)
Price
$189.99
$200
Swing Weight
108
105
Twist Weight
7.15
7.09
Weight
8.1 oz
8 oz
Core
16mm
16mm
Power
55.7 MPH
—
Pop
36.6 MPH
—
Spin
2069 RPM
—
Shape
Wide body
Wide body
Face
Composite
Carbon
Build
Gen 2
Gen 1
Balance
235mm
230mm

Bread & Butter Fat Boy 16mm

This paddle delivers mid-range 55.7 MPH power, plush 16mm feel, rock-solid stability (top 8%) — a control option in a wide body shape.

Pros

  • +Solid pop at 36.6 MPH (68th percentile) for net exchanges
  • +Exceptional stability — 7.15 twist weight is top 8% (avg 6.3), very forgiving on off-center hits
  • +Quick hands — swing weight of 108 is in the 18th percentile (avg 114), easy to maneuver
  • +Wide body maximizes the sweet spot for more forgiveness on off-center hits
  • +Thick 16mm core provides a soft, controlled feel with a forgiving sweet spot

Cons

  • −Shorter face reduces reach compared to elongated paddles

Best For

BeginnersDoubles Specialists
Creator code: PBSTUDIO — 10% OFF

We may earn a commission if you buy through these links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. It never changes the rankings. How we make money

Full details

Selkirk Vanguard Control S2 (midweight)

This paddle delivers plush 16mm feel, rock-solid stability (89th percentile) — a control option in a wide body shape.

Pros

  • +Exceptional stability — 7.09 twist weight is 89th percentile (avg 6.3), very forgiving on off-center hits
  • +Quick hands — swing weight of 105 is in the bottom 9% (avg 114), easy to maneuver
  • +Wide body maximizes the sweet spot for more forgiveness on off-center hits
  • +Thick 16mm core provides a soft, controlled feel with a forgiving sweet spot

Cons

  • −Very light swing weight of 105 (bottom 9%) sacrifices power and plow-through
  • −Shorter face reduces reach compared to elongated paddles
  • −Thick core trades some pop and hand speed for control

Best For

Beginners
Creator code: INF-BRAYDONU

We may earn a commission if you buy through these links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. It never changes the rankings. How we make money

Full details

Not sure which is right for you?

Our quiz matches you to the best paddle based on your specific play style, skill level, and preferences.